MBE Rules · Community Property
Military Disability Offset
Howell v. Howell
The rule
Federal law preempts state courts from dividing VA disability benefits or ordering indemnification when a veteran waives retirement pay for disability — even post-judgment, the former spouse's share shrinks without state remedy.
In plain English
Under federal law, state courts cannot divide Veterans Affairs (VA) disability benefits or require a veteran to compensate their former spouse if the veteran has chosen to waive retirement pay in favor of disability benefits. This means that even after a divorce judgment, the former spouse's entitlement to these benefits can decrease without any state legal recourse.
Worked example
A veteran who receives $2,000 a month in retirement pay decides to waive that amount to receive $2,500 in VA disability benefits after a divorce. The divorce decree initially awarded the former spouse $1,000 of the retirement pay, but since the veteran waived it for disability benefits, the former spouse cannot claim any part of the VA benefits, resulting in a loss of expected income.
Memory hook
VA benefits are off-limits for state courts when disability waives retirement pay.
The trap
Exams may present scenarios where students mistakenly believe state courts can adjust VA benefits post-judgment, leading to incorrect conclusions about the division of assets.
How examiners test it
Questions often involve fact patterns where a veteran's choice between retirement pay and disability benefits impacts the division of property, testing knowledge of federal preemption over state law.
Drill this rule until it can't fail you.
Vrenberg generates unlimited questions on this exact rule, tracks your mastery of it, and brings it back until it sticks.
More Community Property rules
- Interspousal Fiduciary Duty · Cal. Fam. Code § 721; § 1100(e)
- Management and Control of CP · Cal. Fam. Code § 1100(a)-(d)
- Equal Division at Dissolution · Cal. Fam. Code § 2550
- Putative Spouse Doctrine · Cal. Fam. Code § 2251
- Business Goodwill · Marriage of Foster (goodwill)
- Severance Pay · Severance pay (Cal.)