MBE Rules · Criminal Law
Corporate Criminal Liability
Corporate and vicarious liability
The rule
Corporations are liable for crimes of agents acting within the scope of employment intending to benefit the entity; high-managerial ratification is required under the MPC for non-regulatory crimes.
In plain English
Corporations can be held responsible for crimes committed by their employees if those employees are acting within their job duties and with the intention of benefiting the corporation. However, for certain serious crimes, the corporation must have high-level management approve or ratify the conduct to be held liable.
Worked example
A sales manager at a corporation falsifies sales records to inflate profits, intending to boost the company's stock price. The CEO later learns of this and endorses the manager's actions to maintain the inflated profits. The corporation is liable for the crime due to the CEO's ratification.
Memory hook
Corporations can commit crimes too, but only if the boss gives a thumbs up!
The trap
Exams often present scenarios where employees act outside their authority, leading students to mistakenly conclude that the corporation is liable when it is not. Students must carefully assess the scope of employment and intent to benefit the corporation.
How examiners test it
Questions typically involve fact patterns where an employee commits a crime, requiring candidates to analyze whether the actions were within the scope of employment and if there was managerial ratification.
Drill this rule until it can't fail you.
Vrenberg generates unlimited questions on this exact rule, tracks your mastery of it, and brings it back until it sticks.